top of page

Jeff Rath Alleges Smith Interference in Alberta Petition Process, Citing Texts

Oct 27
4 min read

EDMONTON — Jeff Rath is accusing Premier Danielle Smith of behind-the-scenes interference in Alberta’s citizen initiative process, citing a June 30, 2025 text exchange that he says raises questions about her dealings with competing petition organizers.


In a media alert supplied to Alberta Radio, Rath argues that a message about waiting for new petition rules was intended for Thomas Lukaszuk, the proponent of the Alberta Forever Canada petition. The screenshots also contain a reply attributed to Smith explicitly saying the message was intended for Rath.


The allegation of collusion is Rath’s interpretation of the exchange. Alberta Radio has reviewed the three supplied screenshots but has not independently authenticated the original messages or obtained the complete conversation. The images do not, by themselves, establish that Smith coordinated with Lukaszuk or directed Elections Alberta’s decisions.


The June 30 message at the centre of the allegation


The first screenshot shows a conversation with a contact saved as “Danielle,” with a timestamp of June 30, 2025 at 10:50 AM. Rath identifies that contact as Premier Danielle Smith. The incoming message reads:


Told you not to submit before the new rules came in. This has to be conducted under the old thresholds.


The screenshot then shows an Elections Alberta link and another incoming message: “I’ll be curious what he does with yours.”


Rath’s response, shown in the next image, includes criticism of the petition process and says: “You obviously meant to send this text to Lukaszuk,” followed by a quotation of the earlier message.


The wording matters: the screenshot says “before the new rules came in.” The accompanying media alert paraphrases this as “until the new rules came in.” The quotation above follows the screenshot.


First supplied screenshot of the exchange Rath attributes to Danielle Smith, dated June 30, 2025, discussing old petition thresholds.

Screenshot 1 of 3 supplied to Alberta Radio. The contact is saved as “Danielle”; Rath identifies the sender as Premier Danielle Smith. Authenticity has not been independently verified.


Second supplied screenshot showing Rath’s replies and his assertion that the earlier message was intended for Thomas Lukaszuk.

Screenshot 2 of 3: the outgoing messages challenge the petition process and suggest that the earlier text was intended for Lukaszuk.


The reply attributed to Smith


The third screenshot contains an incoming reply that directly disputes Rath’s suggestion about the intended recipient:


No I meant to send it to you


I told you and Mitch to wait til the new rules came in and it sounds like you did


A further message reads: “That’s why I want to see what the CEO does with your petition. Let me know.” Rath then replies: “We are going in on Thursday.” Another incoming message says: “This one was stamped June 5 and posted today.”


In his media alert, Rath disputes the explanation attributed to Smith. He says she had not told him to wait for the new rules and that his side had already intended to do so. He argues that the timing points to involvement with Lukaszuk’s petition. That assertion is not corroborated by a separate Smith–Lukaszuk exchange in the material supplied.


Third supplied screenshot showing the reply attributed to Smith saying the message was intended for Rath and referring to new petition rules.

Screenshot 3 of 3 includes the reply attributed to Smith, Rath’s stated plan to submit on Thursday, and a reference to a June 5 date.


What the official petition record confirms


Elections Alberta’s June 30, 2025 notice confirms approval of the Alberta Forever Canada policy proposal asking whether Alberta should remain in Canada. It states that the application had been received and approved before Bill 54’s relevant changes took effect, so the earlier requirements applied.


The Alberta government’s published timeline places the relevant legislative changes coming into force on July 4, 2025.


Elections Alberta’s December 1, 2025 results release records a July 30 start for signature collection and an October 28 start for verification. It lists the required threshold as 293,976 signatures and reports 404,293 verified signatures after statistical sampling, declaring the petition successful under the requirements in effect on June 30.


That record is important to Rath’s allegation: it shows Lukaszuk’s petition succeeded under the older requirements. It does not show that it was granted the lower threshold described in the media alert. The supplied material also does not establish the alert’s separate claim that Lukaszuk was lobbying Smith at the time.


Rath’s political criticism and the unanswered questions


Rath’s release goes beyond the intended recipient of a single text. He alleges Smith manipulated the petition and subsequent referendum process, and argues that the exchange undermines her credibility with voters on both sides of the independence debate. Those are his allegations and political conclusions, rather than findings established by the screenshots.


The exchange leaves questions that would require fuller records and on-record explanations: what earlier discussion the message refers to, whose application was being discussed at each point, and whether there were related communications between Smith and Lukaszuk. A contact label and cropped conversation cannot resolve those questions alone.


No fresh on-record response from Smith or Lukaszuk to this media alert was available in the material reviewed for this article. The reply attributed to Smith within the screenshots is included above because it directly addresses Rath’s claim that the message was misdirected.


For Albertans who signed petitions, volunteered or voted, transparent answers about the process remain a matter of public interest. Publishing the exchange with its competing explanations and the official timeline allows readers to examine the claim without treating an allegation as an established finding.


Source material


Reporting: Alberta Radio / OSx/AC3 News Aggregation. Primary material: the media alert attributed to Jeff Rath and the three screenshots supplied to Alberta Radio; Elections Alberta’s June 30 and December 1, 2025 releases; and the Alberta government’s Bill 54 implementation timeline. The screenshots are reproduced as supplied.





Support Alberta Radio


Your $50 contribution helps cover station operating costs and supports Alberta Radio’s news, music and community programming.


$50 Donation - Alberta Radio Show
CA$50.00
Donate $50

bottom of page