
Kimberly Polman's "Terrible Mistake," and the Jihadist Threat Canada Still Has to Face

This is an opinion commentary.
Last month, Kimberly Polman pleaded guilty in a British Columbia court to leaving Canada to participate in the activities of a terrorist group: the Islamic State, also called ISIS or Daesh. As of Nov. 14, 2026, she had not been sentenced. The agreed facts, reported by The Canadian Press and CBC News, are a clear public record of how a Canadian was recruited — and of what that organization did to her.
I am not writing this to smear Muslims, or Islam as a faith practiced by millions of peaceful people. Many Muslim Canadians have rejected ISIS, al-Qaeda and Hamas in the strongest terms. I am writing it because jihadist groups still recruit, still plot, and still claim a religious licence for violence that Canada and the United States cannot treat as a misunderstanding.
A Canadian recruitment story
Polman converted to Islam in 2003. About a decade later, the agreed facts say, she began researching Islamic extremist ideology online. In 2014 she entered into a marriage, conducted online, with Suhayb Muhammad Adan, a Kenyan ISIS fighter of Somali descent. By July 2015 she planned to join him in Syria. Data from her computer showed she knew the Islamic State was a listed terrorist entity, that Syria was a war zone, and that she could be arrested for going.
She travelled through Vienna and Turkey and was smuggled in through Islamic State safe houses, arriving in August 2015. She turned over her U.S. passport — she is a dual Canadian-American citizen — to the group. Adan divorced her in January 2016. That October she married another Islamic State member, Safraz Ali, who, the facts say, produced explosives and improvised bombs. Coalition forces captured her near Baghouz on Jan. 27, 2019. After years in the Roj camp, she was repatriated in October 2022, arrested in Montreal, later lived under strict conditions in B.C., and was charged in 2024. On Oct. 8, 2026, she pleaded guilty; a second charge was dropped.
In an April 3, 2019, letter from Roj camp, Polman told "Dear Canadians" she had "made a terrible mistake," coming in the belief she could help as a nurse, and was "immediately... thrown into a world of intense fear, unable to leave." She said she was imprisoned, tortured and raped, and that ISIS regarded her as a traitor. Those claims are her account. The agreed facts also show she knew what the group was before she left, and later married a bomb-maker for it. Both can be true. That is a recruitment pipeline: it finds people in a hard place — she was unemployed, in low-income housing, with a learning disability — sells them purpose, and then uses them.
The threat is not a relic of 2015
It would be comforting to treat Polman's case as a closed chapter. Security agencies say it is not.
CSIS, in its 2024 and 2025 public reporting, has been blunt. In 2024 it said the threat of religiously and ideologically motivated violent extremism grew, and that multiple religiously motivated extremists were arrested in Canada, "mainly motivated by the conflicts in the Middle East, inspired by Daesh," and planning low-sophistication attacks on soft targets. In 2025, it said the religiously motivated threat, and the risk of a domestic lone-actor attack, "increased significantly" after the Israel-Hamas war began, and that at least seven priority investigations involving mobilization to violence were motivated, in whole or in part, by that conflict. Since 2014, CSIS has counted 20 violent extremist attacks in Canada, causing 29 deaths and at least 60 injuries; since 2022, it has helped disrupt at least 24 such actions. Those figures cover more than one ideology, including a jihadist stream the service says will continue to pose a domestic threat.
The RCMP, in a ministerial briefing later reported by Global News, said that from April 1, 2023, to March 31, 2024, 25 people were accused of 83 terrorism-related charges — a 488 per cent increase — and that police had foiled six plots in 12 months. Three minors and six young adults were among those charged; another eight youths faced terrorism peace bonds. The briefing linked the spike in part to renewed interest in the Islamic State, and also noted charges against far-right actors. Honesty requires that distinction. It does not require us to look away from the ISIS-inspired cases.
Those cases are on the record. In July 2024, the RCMP charged Ahmed Fouad Mostafa Eldidi and his son Mostafa with terrorism offences, including conspiracy to commit murder, in what CSIS later described as the advanced stages of an alleged ISIL-inspired mass-casualty plot in the Toronto area. As of a 2025 Public Safety briefing, those proceedings were still before the courts. In Calgary, Zakarya Rida Hussein pleaded guilty after posting ISIS recruitment videos, sharing a bomb-making video, and keeping written instructions in a notebook; he was sentenced to six years in September 2024. Muhammad Shahzeb Khan, a Pakistani national living in Canada, was arrested here in 2024 over an ISIS-inspired plot against a Jewish centre in New York and pleaded guilty in the United States in April 2026, the U.S. Department of Justice said.
That is the record: not a smear of a religious community, but plots, charges, guilty pleas and official warnings.
The flags change. The method does not.
Over recent decades the brand names have shifted. Al-Qaeda. Al-Qaeda in Iraq. The Islamic State of Iraq, then ISIS, ISIL or Daesh. Affiliates from Africa to Afghanistan. Hamas and Hezbollah, both listed as terrorist entities by Canada, operate under their own banners. The logos change. The method does not: sacralize violence, recruit, treat civilians as expendable, and demand a political order that cannot be reconciled with free, equal, secular civil law.
Extremist propagandists call their war a jihad and wrap it in religious language. That claim should be named, and so should the answer from countless Muslims who say this is a distortion, not a duty. Violent jihad as these groups practice it is an extremist project. It is not "an Islamic value" ordinary Muslim neighbours are required to share. Conflating the two is what the recruiters want, and it is unfair to Canadians who have warned their own communities against these groups.
One law, freely entered
The same line matters at home. In 2015, Parliament made forced marriage a crime. Section 293.1 of the Criminal Code says that anyone who celebrates, aids or participates in a marriage rite knowing one person is marrying against their will can face up to five years in prison. Consent is not optional in this country.
Forced marriage is a real problem in Canada, and it is not the property of one faith. A 2013 report by the South Asian Legal Clinic of Ontario documented 219 confirmed or suspected cases in Ontario and Quebec between 2010 and 2012, mostly women and girls, including people identified as Muslim, Hindu and Christian. A 2025 Quebec access-to-information response found no court cases under section 293.1 in that province since 2015. The honest conclusion is not that the problem vanished, but that the law already rejects forced marriage and should be used when the evidence is there.
The same principle decided Ontario's debate over faith-based family arbitration. In 2005, after a proposal to use Islamic legal principles in official family arbitration, Premier Dalton McGuinty ended it: there would be "no Sharia law in Ontario," "no religious arbitration in Ontario," and "one law for all Ontarians." In 2006, the Family Statute Law Amendment Act confined enforceable family arbitration to Ontario or Canadian law. People may still seek religious advice. They may not stand up a parallel family-law system a court must enforce. That defends the Charter: equality before the law, and the right not to be trapped in a private legal order one did not truly choose.
When protest stops telling the truth about Hamas
The war in Gaza has produced real grief and a protected right to protest government policy. It has also produced a blur, especially on some campuses, between criticizing Israel and excusing a listed terrorist organization.
In April 2024, at a Vancouver Art Gallery rally, chants of "long live Oct. 7" were heard, and a speaker described Hamas's attack as "heroic and brave." B.C. Premier David Eby called the remarks "the most hateful" he could imagine and "reprehensible." Vancouver Mayor Ken Sim called the event a "celebration of terrorism and antisemitism." The same week, McGill University said it had seen video of "unequivocally antisemitic language and intimidating behaviour." An encampment went up at UBC. At the University of Toronto, Justice Markus Koehnen granted an injunction on July 2, 2024, and protesters dismantled the camp the next day.
I will not pretend every student in those camps, or every professor who spoke about Gaza, was a Hamas supporter. That would be sloppy and unfair. But when activists praise a massacre, when Jewish students are left "particularly alone on campuses," in Eby's words, and when some academic spaces struggle to say plainly that Hamas is a terrorist group, the line has been crossed. Youth are not "indoctrinated" by an entire profession. They are vulnerable, as Polman was, to a story that launders extremist violence as resistance. Institutions that cannot draw that line are being careless, not brave.
The cost of a quiet condemnation
This is my opinion, and I will say it plainly. Too many institutions that should have drawn a hard line — some Muslim leaders and organizations, and too many Western governments, universities and cultural institutions — have not condemned jihadist groups loudly enough, or consistently enough, when it counted.
That is not a claim that no one spoke. They did. In September 2014, 126 Muslim scholars issued an open letter denouncing ISIS and its abuse of Islamic texts. Canadian Muslim organizations and imams have condemned the Islamic State. After the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, some Muslim and civic leaders in Canada called the massacre what it was. Those voices matter, and they should be credited.
But condemnation that has to be hunted for is not the same as a clear public standard. When a listed terrorist group is praised at a rally, when campuses struggle to say the word "Hamas," and when political fear of being called intolerant becomes a reason to soften the language, victims notice. Extremists notice too. In my view, the silence, and the half-statements, have made it easier for these groups to recruit and harder for decent people — including many Muslim Canadians — to isolate them.
What official inquiries found in Britain — and what Canada already records
The failures are not only about terrorism overseas. They are also about whether institutions will name a crime when the facts are ugly.
In 2014, Professor Alexis Jay's independent inquiry found a conservative estimate of 1,400 children were sexually exploited in Rotherham, England, between 1997 and 2013. Children as young as 11 were raped, trafficked and intimidated. In Rochdale, nine men were convicted in 2012 in a grooming-gang case that later reviews found had been mishandled for years, and further prosecutions followed. In Telford, an independent inquiry chaired by Tom Crowther and published in 2022 concluded that more than 1,000 children had been sexually exploited over decades, and that obvious evidence had been ignored, including because of "nervousness about race."
Baroness Louise Casey's 2025 national audit of group-based child sexual exploitation in England and Wales was just as blunt about the system. She found fragmented responses, flawed data, too little justice, and victims as young as 10. Ethnicity data was missing for two-thirds of perpetrators, so she said national claims about ethnicity could not be supported. In local data from three police forces, though, the audit found clear evidence of over-representation among suspects of Asian and Pakistani-heritage men, and it described organizations avoiding the topic for fear of appearing racist. Those are official findings, not a licence to smear a community. They are a warning against looking away.
Canada has its own documented harm, and it should be discussed without ethnic generalization. Statistics Canada reports that police recorded 5,070 human-trafficking incidents from 2014 to 2024. Of the identified victims, 93 per cent were women and girls, and most were young: 63 per cent of identified victims were under 25. Child sexual exploitation, including online offences, is a recorded and serious problem in this country. The duty is the same as in Rotherham: protect children, prosecute offenders, and do not let fear of a political argument outrank the facts.
How these movements treat women and girls
The same groups and movements leave a record with women and girls that no serious country should romanticize.
Since seizing power in August 2021, the Taliban have made Afghanistan, in UNESCO's words, "the only country in the world where secondary and higher education is strictly forbidden to girls and women." In an August 2025 statement, UNESCO's director-general said nearly 2.2 million girls and women were barred from school beyond the primary level.
ISIS's crimes against the Yazidis were in a different register of horror. In June 2016, the United Nations commission of inquiry on Syria concluded that the Islamic State was committing genocide against the Yazidis, and that the group had committed crimes against humanity, including sexual slavery. The commission estimated that at least 3,200 Yazidi women and girls remained in ISIS captivity, mainly in Syria.
Child marriage is wider than any one conflict, and it is not the product of one faith. UNICEF has estimated that 640 million girls and women alive today were married in childhood. The point is not to invent a single culprit. It is to say that forced and child marriage, sexual slavery, and the ban on girls' schooling are not abstract "cultural differences." They are documented harms. Canadian law, and Canadian opinion, should say so without apology.
A record of persecution — including at home
Open Doors, in its World Watch List for 2026, estimates that more than 388 million Christians face high levels of persecution and discrimination for their faith. In the reporting period, it counted 4,849 Christians killed worldwide because of their Christian identity; 3,490 of those killings were in Nigeria, which it has described for years as among the most violent places in the world for Christians, under pressure from Islamist militant groups including Boko Haram and Islamic State West Africa Province. Pakistan ranked eighth. The list also recorded the June 2025 Islamic State attack on a church in Damascus, in which at least 22 worshippers were killed. These figures come from a monitoring organization, not a government census, and they should be read that way. They are still a serious, sourced record of who is being targeted.
Canada is not Nigeria. It is not Syria. But it is not immune to attacks on churches. A CBC News review found that at least 33 Canadian churches burned to the ground between May 2021 and December 2023. Investigators confirmed 24 of those fires as arson; two were ruled accidental; the rest were deemed suspicious or were still under investigation. Most of the major cases remained unsolved, and where charges were laid, police had not established a clear motive, CBC reported. The wave followed the 2021 announcements of possible unmarked graves at former residential school sites, a history that is itself a wound in this country. None of that licenses arson. A church burned is a church burned, and a country that believes in religious freedom should say so.
Independent reporting on cases like these takes time. If this commentary is useful, a $50 contribution helps keep Alberta Radio on the air.
The war business, and a demand for peace
There is a last point, and I will label it as mine. Jihadist groups choose their victims and are responsible for their crimes. But war also has a market. The Stockholm International Peace Research Institute reports world military expenditure rose to $2.887 trillion in 2025, the 11th consecutive year of growth, and the highest total SIPRI has recorded. The United States remained the largest spender, at $954 billion. Major international arms transfers in 2021–25 were 9.2 per cent higher than in 2016–20, with the United States accounting for 42 per cent of global exports.
Those are facts about a world that is arming. My opinion is that too much conflict is sustained, and too often coerced, by people and institutions that profit when wars go on. "Without war the industry would fall" is a saying, not a statute, but the incentive is obvious. Peace does not come from pretending ISIS or Hamas are misunderstood charities. It comes from telling the truth about extremist groups, enforcing Canadian law, refusing to smear whole religions — and confronting the war industry instead of romanticizing it. The goal is not the next flag or the next contract. It is global peace.
Polman called her decision a terrible mistake. The groups that recruited her are not a mistake. They are a threat. Canada and the United States should treat them that way — and still hold the door open to every person, including every Muslim Canadian, who wants to live under one civil law, in peace.
Sources
CBC News / The Canadian Press, Nov. 14, 2026: Polman's letter and the agreed statement of facts
Global News, May 2025: RCMP ministerial briefing on terrorism charges
Public Safety Canada, April 2025: Toronto terror-plot arrests (Eldidi)
Public Prosecution Service of Canada, Sept. 17, 2024: Hussein sentence
South Asian Legal Clinic of Ontario, 2013 forced-marriage report, via CBC News and the report PDF
Quebec Ministry of Justice, 2025 access-to-information response on ss. 293.1, 293.2 and 273.3(1)
Legislative Assembly of Ontario: Family Statute Law Amendment Act, 2006 (Bill 27)
CBC News, April 30, 2024: Eby condemns praise of the Hamas attack
CBC News, July 2024: University of Toronto encampment injunction and dismantling
Wilson Center / Letter to al-Baghdadi, Sept. 19, 2014, 126 Muslim scholars and the letter PDF
BBC News, 2014: Jay report on Rotherham, conservative estimate of 1,400 children
GOV.UK, 2025: Casey national audit on group-based child sexual exploitation
GOV.UK, 2025: government statement on the Casey audit findings
UNESCO, Aug. 14, 2025: 2.2 million Afghan girls still banned from school
UN News, June 16, 2016: commission of inquiry on ISIS genocide against the Yazidis
UNICEF: Is an end to child marriage within reach? (640 million estimate)
Open Doors World Watch List 2026 and the 2026 advocacy report
CBC News, Jan. 2024: 33 Canadian churches burned, 24 confirmed arsons, May 2021–Dec. 2023



