
The Count Is Final, the Fight Isn't: Smith's Texts, New Bills, and a Hard Week on Alberta's Streets

Jason LaFace | Alberta Radio | Friday, October 30, 2026
The numbers are official now. Eleven days after Albertans went to the polls, Elections Alberta has posted the certified results of the October 19 referendum, and the verdict on the big question is not close.
But if anyone in the premier's office hoped the final count would close the book on the independence debate, this week said otherwise. A leaked text exchange between Premier Danielle Smith and separatist lawyer Jeffrey Rath has turned into a question period brawl. The legislature is moving new bills on schools and online child exploitation. Alberta's new health bureaucracy just fired eight senior leaders. And on the streets of Calgary and Edmonton, police spent the week laying charges in a kidnapping, a downtown drug ring, a disturbing human-remains case and a deadly crash into a fire truck.
Here is where things stand on Friday.
The Referendum: Official Results and the Next Steps
Elections Alberta released the official results on October 29.
On Question 10, the separation question, 74.95 per cent of voters (1,556,316 ballots) chose to remain in Canada. 25.05 per cent (520,233 ballots) voted to start the legal process toward a binding separation vote.
That is a clear answer, and it lines up with what polling had shown all year: roughly seven in ten Albertans wanted to stay. Anyone who believes in Alberta self-determination, as I do, has to respect a number like that. Democracy cuts both ways.
The rest of the ballot tells a more interesting story.
All five immigration and citizenship questions passed, with Yes support ranging from about 51.78 to 58.06 per cent. Question 1 drew 54.86 per cent Yes, and Question 2 came in at 52.46 per cent. The five questions covered immigration control, eligibility for provincial programs, a residency waiting period, fees for non-permanent residents, and proof of citizenship to vote. These were separate proposals, rather than one combined policy.
All four constitutional questions failed, with Yes support between about 42.44 and 47.28 per cent. Those would have backed the premier in lobbying other provinces on constitutional amendments to claw powers back from Ottawa and to abolish the Senate.
Turnout was 70.4 per cent on the top questions, well above the 60.5 per cent who voted in the 2023 provincial election. There were 3,148,205 eligible electors.
Every question was non-binding. The government is not legally forced to act on any of them. Politically, though, the immigration results give Edmonton a mandate to press Ottawa. The constitutional failures suggest Albertans want more control over their own affairs without reopening the Constitution itself.
Smith's position since referendum night has been firm. In a government-paid televised address the day after the vote, she said: "Alberta will remain a province of Canada. Albertans will continue to be Canadians." She promised that "for as long as I am premier," there would be no further referendum on independence.
The separatist movement did not take that quietly. Rath, a co-founder of the Alberta Prosperity Project who played a role in the push that ended Jason Kenney's premiership, said within a day that he would seek a special general meeting of the United Conservative Party to remove Smith. He accused her of betraying the people who helped elect her.
The Smith–Rath Texts: What We Actually Know
That feud is the backdrop to this week's biggest political story.
On Tuesday, Rath posted screenshots of a text exchange he says took place with the premier on the morning of June 30, 2025. That was four days before the Smith government's changes to the Citizen Initiative Act took effect.
The message from a contact labelled "Danielle" reads, in part: "told you not to submit before the new rules came in. This has to be conducted under the old thresholds." It then says she would be "curious what he does with yours."
Rath replied that she had "obviously" meant to send the text to Thomas Lukaszuk, the former deputy premier who led the Forever Canadian petition. Elections Alberta approved Lukaszuk's petition application the same day.
According to the screenshots, Smith answered that she had meant it for Rath, writing: "I told you and Mitch to wait til the new rules came in and it sounds like you did." "Mitch" is Mitch Sylvestre, CEO of the Alberta Prosperity Project and president of a UCP constituency association.
The context matters. Lukaszuk applied under the old rules, which meant he needed about 294,000 signatures in 90 days. The new rules, in force July 4, 2025, cut the requirement to about 177,000 signatures and stretched the collection window to four months. Sylvestre filed the separation petition that same day, July 4. Lukaszuk's petition ultimately gathered 438,568 valid signatures. The separatist Stay Free Alberta petition gathered about 223,000 verified signatures.
Rath's own spin is that the texts show Smith either colluding with Lukaszuk or quietly acting as "a secret separatist." By his telling, she is unelectable either way. He has offered no other evidence, and he has said Smith never actually told him to wait.
In question period Wednesday, Opposition Leader Naheed Nenshi read the "wait til the new rules came in" line aloud. He accused the premier of coaching the separatists on how to time their petition and of changing the law to help them.
Smith did not dispute that the screenshots were real. Her defence is that she was explaining the rules during a transition period, something she says she does for anyone who asks. She pointed out that she also met with country singer Corb Lund about his anti-coal-mining petition.
"I will talk to anybody who is trying to understand the citizen initiative process and let them know how the rules apply," she told the house. "It's my job to help explain when legislation and regulations are coming, and I did that."
So what do we know? We know the premier was texting a separatist organizer about filing timing for a petition, under rules her own government was changing that same week. We do not know of any evidence that she directed the separatist campaign, or that she tried to sink Lukaszuk's petition. No one has independently authenticated the full exchange, and the screenshots cut off mid-sentence.
Both camps want this to mean something bigger than it does. For a premier who campaigned for "remain," being attacked from the left as a separatist sympathizer and from the separatist flank as a federalist plant is a strange place to be. It may also be the most honest picture of where she sits.
In the Legislature: Bill 35 and Bill 36
While the texts dominated question period, the government kept tabling legislation.
Bill 35, introduced October 29 by Education Minister Demetrios Nicolaides, is an omnibus education and child care bill. The proposals described in the supplied roundup include:
It gives the education minister power to set provincial report-card standards. Letter grades are possible, but the government says that hasn't been decided.
It requires ministerial approval before a school can be named or renamed.
It requires school boards to disclose what happens on professional development and other non-instructional days, within 60 days.
It sets formal procedures for handling parent concerns.
It requires licensed daycares to promptly notify parents of serious or critical incidents involving their children.
The target is the 2027–28 school year.
From where I sit, much of this is overdue transparency. Parents fund the system and they are entitled to know what happens on PD days. They should never learn from a stranger that their toddler was hurt at daycare.
The report-card and school-naming powers are a different matter. Those pull decisions away from locally elected trustees and toward one minister's desk. Conservatives who complain about Ottawa centralizing power should watch for the same habit in Edmonton.
Bill 36, as described in the supplied roundup, would update Alberta's child exploitation laws to deal with offences committed online. The full detail is still coming out of the legislature. Even so, the principle should get support from every corner of the house. Predators moved online years ago, and the law has been slow to follow.
Health Governance: Firings and a Court Order
The province's restructuring of the health system is producing turmoil at the top.
On October 26, Acute Care Alberta dismissed eight senior leaders, calling it a "leadership realignment." The portfolios affected cover emergency care, women's health, medicine, diagnostic imaging and legal services.
Separately, Alberta and Alberta Health Services have been ordered to release records of any warnings given to the fired former AHS CEO before her dismissal. This ties into the long-running fallout over AHS procurement, including the contract controversy that has drawn RCMP attention.
I have long argued that Alberta's health system was too centralized and too unaccountable. Breaking up the AHS monolith was the right instinct. But reform means more than reshuffling the deck chairs. Albertans who are waiting in emergency rooms deserve to know why these eight leaders were let go, and what was in those warnings. Transparency is not optional when the public is paying.
Municipal Friction: Photo Radar and Bike Lanes
In Edmonton, the fight between city hall and the province continues.
The province approved just one of Edmonton's eight requests to restore speed-on-green intersection cameras. Four were rejected and three are still under review. Mayor Andrew Knack says the province ignored the city's safety data. Transportation Minister Devin Dreeshen says the rejected sites didn't meet provincial criteria.
City staff also estimate that removing some bike and active-transportation infrastructure would cost $150 million to $170 million. The province is planning bike-lane legislation, but the details are not yet public.
I am no fan of photo radar as a cash machine, and the province was right to rein it in. Still, a $150-million-plus bill to tear out infrastructure that's already built deserves a hard look before anyone swings a jackhammer. Spending money to unspend money is not fiscal conservatism.
Crime: Calgary
Drug-related kidnapping. Calgary police have charged two men after a woman was allegedly held against her will in a southeast home in the 2000 block of 37 Street S.E. on October 12 and 13.
Police say the case was drug-related. Investigators seized:
a sawed-off rifle
about 607 grams of fentanyl
about 360 grams of methamphetamine
GHB
a stolen motorcycle
Joseph Sarazen, 45, and Jordan Taylor, 36, are charged. Police are still looking for Dmetri Tyrone Cappo, 33, who is wanted on warrants. Anyone with information is asked to call 403-266-1234.
The reported fentanyl seizure is substantial. Its potential harm depends on concentration and other factors; police have not provided a toxicological assessment in the supplied material.
Operation Restore. In a separate downtown investigation, five people face a combined 30 charges for allegedly selling drugs to people experiencing homelessness. Police executed 15 warrants and seized crack cocaine, methamphetamine and weapons. Two of the accused are scheduled in court today.
Preying on the most vulnerable people in the city is about as low as it gets. Compassion for people on the street starts with getting the dealers off it.
Skyview Ranch human remains. On the morning of Tuesday, October 27, police went to a home in the 200 block of Skyview Ranch Road N.E. for a welfare check. During a search, officers found evidence consistent with human remains.
Michael Lee, 49, and Helen Lee, 50, are each charged with indignity to a dead body. Both are in custody and are also scheduled to appear in court today.
An autopsy was scheduled for Thursday. The victim's name will be released once the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner confirms their identity. Police have treated it as a suspicious death and searched the property and surrounding area. Tips can go to police at 403-266-1234 or to Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-8477.
Crime: Edmonton
Fatal crash into a fire truck. A 44-year-old man died after his minivan ran a red light at Kingsway Avenue and 101 Street around 8:30 p.m. on October 27. The van hit a northbound fire truck.
Edmonton police say speed and alcohol are believed to have been factors. The fire truck's driver suffered injuries that are not life-threatening.
The fatal collision is another reminder of the risks facing road users and emergency crews. Police continue to assess the circumstances.
Detainee drop-offs and the crime numbers. Police Chief Warren Dreichel says the Edmonton Police Service received no advance warning before released detainees were dropped off in Chinatown. A neighbourhood that has already been through enough was handed another problem without notice. Dreichel says EPS is now coordinating with corrections and the RCMP.
Separately, EPS’s October 14 public update reported a 13.6 per cent decline in average crime severity in the Downtown Branch Crime Treatment Zone from January 1 to September 30, compared with the same period in 2025. Public-generated calls fell 7.6 per cent, while officer-generated calls rose 42.5 per cent. EPS also reported a 17 per cent year-to-date decline in violent crime in West Branch.
These are specific geographic and time-period comparisons. They should not be presented as proof of an eight per cent citywide decline over three months without a matching source.
Commentary: Visible, consistent enforcement deserves attention, alongside clear communication between police, corrections and other agencies serving the same neighbourhoods.
The Work Ahead
Albertans did something remarkable this month. Seven in ten of us turned out, and we gave clear answers. We will stay in Canada. We want more say over immigration and over who uses the services we pay for. And we are not ready to rewrite the Constitution.
That is not a mandate for the status quo. It is a mandate for an Alberta that stands up for itself inside the federation, firmly and on the record.
What it isn't is permission for anyone, separatist or federalist, to keep fighting the last war through screenshots and question period theatrics. The premier should release whatever else exists from those texts and end the guessing. The separatists should accept the count they asked for. The opposition should spend at least as much energy on eight fired health executives and a fentanyl pipeline in southeast Calgary as it does on a 16-month-old text message.
On the streets, the message is simpler. Police in both cities are making arrests and getting results. The courts and corrections system need to keep pace, and keep the cops in the loop.
The count is final. The work is not.
Source: Os1ris News Aggregation.
Reporting note: This article combines the supplied news roundup with commentary by Jason LaFace. Charges and allegations are not findings of guilt. All accused are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court. Police assessments of collision factors remain preliminary.
Support Alberta Radio
Alberta Radio relies on listener support to cover operating costs and keep our news, music and community coverage growing. A $50 contribution helps pay for broadcasting, hosting and the daily work behind the station. Thank you for helping keep Alberta Radio on air.



