
The Vote Was Not a Blank Cheque: Ottawa's Cabinet Rule, Alberta and Quebec

Jason LaFace | Alberta Radio | Thursday, November 12, 2026
Opinion and analysis
Three-quarters of Alberta’s valid votes on Question 10 supported remaining in Canada. That was a decision about Alberta’s place in Confederation, not an endorsement of every decision Mark Carney’s government makes in Ottawa.
Quebec, meanwhile, elected a Parti Québécois minority government. Electing a sovereigntist party is not itself a vote to separate, just as Alberta’s vote to remain does not settle every argument about federal power.
The question is whether Ottawa understands the difference between holding office and possessing a blank cheque. Firearms regulations, emergency powers and a projected $62.3-billion federal deficit make that question worth asking.
Cabinet first, courts later
The Supreme Court heard the federal firearms-ban challenge on November 9 and 10 and reserved its decision. The dispute concerns cabinet’s use of regulatory authority Parliament delegated under the Criminal Code. Those regulations have legal force; whether cabinet exercised that authority lawfully is the issue before the court.
That distinction matters. My objection is political as well as legal: sweeping prohibitions affecting lawful owners deserve direct parliamentary scrutiny and a clear public case, rather than the assumption that an order-in-council ends the argument.
The Emergencies Act case is separate. The Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal found Ottawa’s 2022 invocation unreasonable and beyond its statutory authority. The appeal court also upheld findings of Charter infringements. The Supreme Court has agreed to hear Ottawa’s appeal; permission to appeal does not overturn those rulings or vindicate the government.
The government is entitled to appeal. Citizens are equally entitled to ask why it continues defending extraordinary powers that two courts found were used unlawfully. A limited government should have to explain that choice.
Budget 2026 projects a $62.3-billion deficit for 2026–27. An operating-budget target is not an overall balanced budget. However Ottawa divides operating and capital accounts, borrowing remains borrowing, and taxpayers deserve to see the full bill.
The crime Ottawa would rather not debate
While the Supreme Court considers the firearms regulations, the rest of the country is living with crime that does not wait for a regulation.
In southern Alberta, an October 27–29 sweep by the RCMP and Alberta Sheriffs produced 28 arrests and the execution of 62 warrants for violent offences. The operation covered 28 municipalities, with arrests in 15 communities. Two people were wanted Canada-wide for being unlawfully at large.
That is targeted enforcement directed at outstanding warrants. Arrests are not convictions, but locating people already wanted by the courts is essential police work.
In Edmonton, Dennis Okeymow, 22, awaits sentencing after his May convictions arising from the illegal sale of the rifle used to kill Const. Brett Ryan and Const. Travis Jordan in March 2023. He sold the firearm to a 16-year-old. The Crown seeks 12 to 14 years; the defence seeks time served and probation. Justice John Little has not announced a sentence in the reporting available for this column.
The rifle was sold illegally. The policy question is whether Ottawa’s attention and resources are aimed effectively at trafficking and violent offenders, alongside whatever public-safety case it makes for restrictions on lawful owners.
Calgary police are seeking witnesses to two separate assaults that left men in critical condition: one in a Westwinds parking lot on October 31 and another near 12 Avenue and 14 Street S.W. on November 8. Anyone with information can contact Calgary police at 403-266-1234.
Montreal police have also moved against an alleged jewellery-robbery network involving teenage recruits, some as young as 13. Reporting describes organizers recruiting minors to carry out smash-and-grab thefts. The allegations remain unproven.
A serious federal justice policy should put illegal guns, repeat violence and adults who recruit children near the top of its list. My criticism is that cabinet has too often made licensed owners the centre of its firearms message while these harder enforcement problems persist.
Sign here, then sit down
I will not pretend our own house is spotless.
The UCP has asked all 87 riding presidents to sign a combined non-disclosure agreement and code of conduct declaring that they “recognize, respect, and will abide by” the majority decision on Question 10. CBC reported a Friday deadline, which is tomorrow.
Some presidents, including opponents of independence, object. One unnamed president told CBC that at least 15 were preparing a refusal letter. The report did not identify an announced penalty for declining to sign. That is not evidence of a purge, and it should not be described as one.
The result was decisive: 74.95 per cent of valid votes favoured remaining in Canada, and 25.05 per cent favoured commencing the legal process toward a binding separation referendum. The second option was not itself a binding vote to leave.
Respecting a result is not the same as administering an oath about it. A voluntary party can set organizational rules, but it should consider what those rules do to volunteers’ willingness to argue honestly inside the tent.
Keep the scale honest, though. A party circular is not a Criminal Code regulation. The federal argument concerns the exercise of public power over everyone, including people who never joined the governing party.
The bargain, or the exit
Confederation is a bargain. It is a set of rules about who decides what, who pays, and how power is limited when the people in the capital would rather not be limited.
Alberta tested that bargain at the ballot box. Quebec elected a government committed to sovereignty. These are different mandates, and neither should be inflated into a result voters did not deliver. Both make the future of the federation a live political question.
Ottawa cannot answer that question simply by saying it won office. The legitimacy of governing also depends on respecting legal limits, explaining decisions and listening to provinces whose voters want a different relationship.
Nor does national popularity, whatever the latest poll says, settle the substance of a constitutional disagreement. Consent in Red Deer or Rimouski deserves more than a lecture from the capital.
If Confederation is going to be worth keeping, Ottawa will have to act like a limited government: subject sweeping criminal restrictions to serious parliamentary scrutiny, account for the emergency powers two courts rejected, and treat Alberta’s substantial independence vote and Quebec’s sovereigntist government as signals rather than nuisances.
That does not create an automatic legal right to walk away from Canada. Constitutional change and any separation process have legal requirements. It does create a political obligation to make the bargain worth defending.
The people who voted remain last month can still demand a better deal. Remaining in a federation does not require silence about how it is governed.
The vote was not a blank cheque. Ottawa should stop cashing it as if it were.
Source: AC3/OSx News Aggregation
Support Alberta Radio
Help Alberta Radio cover its operating costs and continue independent Alberta coverage with a $50 donation.



